Realtor ethics case involving gay rights, Montana pastor garnering national attention

The Clinton Community Church sign
Posted at 5:22 PM, Dec 28, 2021

HELENA — A case involving a Missoula-area pastor, gay rights and the National Association of Realtors’ code of ethics may be the first legal test of the code, involving LGBTQ+ discrimination, an advocacy group says.

The head of the LGBTQ+ Real Estate Alliance also told MTN News this week that the pastor and part-time real estate agent should be temporarily suspended from membership in the Realtors’ group – and that the complaint against him should not wait for resolution of the lawsuit.

“Litigation, especially in a pandemic, could be strung out for years,” says Ryan Weyandt, CEO of the group. “This individual, who has been alleged by a member of the community to violate the code of ethics, thus invalidating his membership – for that to be strung out in limbo for years, I think is unacceptable.”

A Missoula Organization of Realtors official said Wednesday that no discipline, in connection to an ethics complaint, can be taken until the complaint is heard and ruled on by an MOR hearings panel.

Clinton Community Church Pastor Brandon Huber is facing a complaint that he violated the NAR Code of Ethics’ prohibition on engaging in “hate speech” against anyone because of their sexual orientation.

Huber is suing the Missoula and national Realtors’ groups, saying the code of ethics should be invalidated because it’s too vague to be enforced and because it tramples on his religious beliefs.

The Missoula Realtors group, which had scheduled a Dec. 2 hearing on the complaint, decided to delay it "for the time being" because of the lawsuit, said its chief executive officer, Jim Bachand.

The National Association of Realtors on Tuesday declined to comment on the status of the ethics proceeding, saying such cases are confidential. However, a spokesman for NAR said it’s confident the code and practice will “withstand judicial scrutiny.”

Bachand said any discipline against Huber wouldn't be decided unless an MOR hearing panel hears the complaint and ruled that an ethical violation occurred. The panel would recommend the discipline, he said.

Weyandt said he believes the Huber case is the first legal test of NAR’s Code of Ethics, which was drawn up in 2020, and that the complaint is among the first involving the code and its ban on discriminatory actions against members of the LGBTQ+ community.

The complaint, filed this summer by a local citizen, accused Huber of engaging in “hate speech” when he withdrew his church from taking part in a Missoula Food Bank free-lunch program after it celebrated gay rights.

In an open letter to his congregation, Huber said the church could no longer partner with the Food Bank’s efforts because promoting gay/transgender rights goes against church doctrine that homosexuality is wrong.

Weyandt said Huber can hold and express any religious belief he wants, but that he can’t profess anti-gay views and still be a member of the Realtors’ group, according to the code of ethics.

“I definitely respect the individual’s right to their freedom of speech and expression, but when you’re clearly violating the governing doctrine of a private institution, that issues membership, that’s a whole other story,” he said.

Weyandt also said Huber is free to continue selling real estate.

However, if a Code of Ethics violation leads to Huber getting kicked out of the Realtors’ group, he would lose access to the Montana Regional multiple-listing service for properties, potentially making it difficult to conduct business as a real-estate agent.

Monforton said the alliance and the National Association of Realtors “won’t be satisfied until every Bible-believing Christian is purged from the real-estate industry.”